Waiting to see if Bashir wins

February 22, 2009 - 12:36 PM by Nicky

Anticipation is already building in Israel today, as people across the country wait to discover if the Israeli movie Waltz with Bashir will win an Oscar at tonight’s ceremony in Los Angeles.

Certainly things look pretty good for the critically acclaimed movie by Ari Folman. It’s already won a string of prestigious awards – from a Golden Globe to an award for the best documentary from the Writers Guild of America, and gambling Web sites are predicting that the Israeli contender for the best foreign film is the most likely of all the entries to win the award.

Critics have also indicated that the movie, which deals with Israel’s invasion of Lebanon in 1982, is their favorite for the prize as – aside from its moving and powerful story – it also breaks new cinematic ground. Critic David Carr, from The New York Times, urged readers to “Put a nickel on Bashir, and keep it there.”
We all love it here when an Israeli film (musician, artist, model etc. etc.) makes good. Last year hopes were high for Beaufort, another moving anti-war film also set in Lebanon, but it was pipped at the post.
For all the success of Folman’s movie, however, there are rumblings of discontent amongst certain sectors of society who feel this, the eighth Israeli Oscar contender, but the one most likely to win, is an anti-Israeli movie.
Folman’s effort to piece together his memories as a combat soldier of the Lebanon War, and particularly the massacre at the Sabra and Shatilla refugee camp in Beirut, are regarded as unjustly demonizing Israel.
Stung by the criticism, one of the film’s backers, the US Foundation for Jewish Culture and Makom, has put out a study guide explaining why the film isn’t unfair. The guide is based on Israel’s own investigation into Sabra and Shatilla, gives the history of the battle, and charts its aftermath.
But why does criticism of Israel’s actions or behavior in a war have to be anti-Israeli? Folman’s film, like Joseph Cedar’s Beaufort before it, is a profound attempt by a soldier to examine a very painful part of his own history and that of his country. It’s soul-searching at its deepest level. And what it reveals about Israel is that this soul searching, doubt and regret is a fundamental part of who we are.
In the media, particularly during the Gaza war, but in many wars and conflicts, Israel is often portrayed as a militaristic nation that doesn’t really give a damn about who gets hurt. Films like Beaufort, and Waltz with Bashir, may not be easy viewing, but they show a completely different truth.

Golden Globe for Waltz with Bashir
Bashir still dancing

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , • Category: Art, General, History and Culture, Movies, Pop Culture, War 

Comments

3 Comments on Waiting to see if Bashir wins

  1. David-Joe on Sun, Feb 22nd 2009 7:02 PM

    2. Of course it MUST portray Israel in a bad light – otherwise how can it win? And there is nothing like Liberal Jews to make such a movie…..

    That was MY war too.I fought in Lebanon and was in the spear head for 3 months as we pushed forward to Beirut.

    I have no idea what this filmamkers experience was – but it is probabaly portrayed as tortured?

    Well, I returned after fighting and I was fine and happy. I felt extremely pleased and proud that I had participated and that the IDF had gone in.

    If the movie is negative as it is being reported I hope it LOSES! Screw the Jews that always portray Israel in a negative light!

  2. Nicky on Mon, Feb 23rd 2009 9:55 AM

    3. I don’t think the movie is negative, and that’s the whole point. Even the Israeli Foreign Ministry is sending out this film with its blessing. It wouldn’t do so unless it felt the film made significant positive comments about life in Israel.

    You shouldn’t mix up criticism of Israeli actions, with a lack of love or patriotism for the country. All countries make mistakes, but it’s only the mature, democratic ones that can admit those errors, try to absorb them, and move on.

    You mention Lebanon many times in your comments, perhaps it would be worth watching the movie. I’m told by friends who fought in Lebanon that it’s actually very true to life.

    And, the film did lose of course. I haven’t seen the other entries it was up against, but it seems a shame. This was a very significant movie, not just for Israel, but also for for film-making in general.

  3. Waltz with Bashir snubbed in LA | ISRAELITY on Tue, Feb 24th 2009 1:24 PM

    4. [...] wisdom unequivocally asserted that the only Best Foreign Language Film Oscar nominee to hold a candle to Waltz with Bashir was France’s The Class – but that even that movie was hardly as technically groundbreaking or [...]

Leave a Comment





© 2009 ISRAELITY | Site by illuminea | Sitemap